My friends and colleagues who follow me for a while are well aware of the fact that my papers about ORIM/ORM were rejected at several conferences. Also, it’s a known fact that this kind of submissions is not welcomed at the conferences in general. My recent work, which was implemented at Braviant Holding with what I would call a smashing success, was only presented at the Postgres conferences. Our three attempts to submit it to any CS/Academic conferences failed. At some point, it became a matter of principle.
We submitted the new version to SOFSEM 2020 in the hope that at DB/SE conference, the topic could feel more appealing. The submissions formate required us to reduce the size of the paper almost twice, but we were still hopeful we would be able to convey a message.
That ended up being only a partial success. The paper was accepted, however, only as a short paper. Reading the reviews, we realized that none of the reviewers understood what it was about (in fact, we got much better reviews fro VLDB, were we got weak accept, which ended up being not enough). To make the paper even shorter, we had to remove all the actual work from the body:), leaving there only the motivation and the conclusion. But as I said, it was the matter of principle.
Then we spend quite a bit of time reworking the presentation. First, Boris wanted it to look more academic, that my older Postgres presentations. But then we started to change it back to more and more visual since we realized that the topic, the motivation, and the reality are pretty much unknown to our audience. Besides, my Postgres presentations were 40-50 minutes long, and here we had only 30 minutes, including questions. I tried very hard to get it to 23-25 minutes.
The last blow came two days before the conference when we were told that the presentations for short papers should be 18 minutes long, including questions, which meant I had only 15 minutes to present. That did not sound feasible, and we were desperate. Boris tried to negotiate our twelve minutes back with the organizers:).
But then a sort of miracle happened. Right before our session began, it turned out that the first person didn’t show up, and I claimed all the time I could. Unfortunately, I already cut several slides out of my presentation (I put them pack in the pdf, which I previously published here). After all, I was able to bring my point across, and I think that everybody present there, enjoyed the presentation. How I wish I won’t be presenting on the first day because then I `would convince more people to come. But in any case, I hope that now we will be able to publish a full version of the paper somewhere.